December 17th

Box #17 in our count down is Ostafrikasaurus…

Days 1-5 of the count down.
Days 6-10 in the count down
Days 11-15 of the count down
Days 16-20 of the count down
Days 21-25 of the count down
Ostafrikasaurus, the first Spinosaurus cousin?

Ostafrikasaurus: the “Lizard from German East Africa”

Back in the days of adventure and exploration, with the likes of Teddy Roosevelt and just before the discovery of King Tut’s tomb in Egypt, eight teeth where found in what is now Tanzania. At the time the area was known as Deutsch-Ostafrika, the German name for the colony of “German East Africa” in the early 1900s. The teeth where thought to look similar to a creature called Labrosaurus.

The only problem? Labrosaurus was named on bits and pieces at the height of the Bone Wars, a period of heavy competition between paleontologists Edward Drinker Cope and Othniel Charles Marsh. These two men had many assistants. Records were easily misplaced, lost, or actively sabotaged, and this often led to confusion. Plus there was great incentive to give each new handful of scattered pieces a separate name. In part this was because there wasn’t enough overlapping pieces to compare and be sure it was the same as a different handful of pieces. Like lumping all the puzzle pieces with flowers or bits of cloud until you have enough of the piles to start putting them together and figure out that there are two or three different puzzles. Or even all part of the same puzzle.

Fossils like these often get stuffed in a drawer and forgotten about for a while. In the year 2000, the teeth were determined to look more like those of Ceratosaurus, a three-horned meat-eater from North America. Fast forward between 2007 to 2012, and more research comparing these teeth and other “puzzle piece piles” determined that pieces assigned to Labrosaurus were actually Allosaurus, and others were Ceratosaurus. Several of the eight teeth were officially assigned as Ceratosaurus teeth, but one tooth was different.

Some proposed that they looked like those of Baryonix, an early relative of the famous Spinosaurus. If true, then the animal to which the tooth belonged would be the first evidence of a relative of Spinosaurus from the late Jurassic. A group that is most commonly known from the Cretaceous.

Ostafrikasaurus was officially named in 2012, but there is still heavy debate on whether the teeth are of a spinosaurid or a ceratosaurid.

Ostafrikasaurus offers an example of areas of paleontology that are more controversial. Should we name new animals based on teeth alone, or should we simply catalogue them and leave them in a drawer until more complete fossils are found? Perhaps making unusual hypothesis and naming unique fragments like teeth should be encouraged because of the conversation they inspire, which ultimately ensures that when more complete fossils are found comparisons are made with the handful of existing fossils. Rather than allowing fragments to lay dormant in a drawer and be forgotten.

It also brings to mind the possibility of a group of dinosaurs previously unknown to the time, and that is exciting! After all, what is the likelihood that modern egg-laying mammals will fossilize for future paleontologists to discover? For millions of years before or after a particular time in Earth’s grand history, there are animals that are the last-surviving members of their group, or the first pioneers. All too often, they are rare examples of their kind, and the possibility of being fossilized, the possibility of our researchers finding them and knowing they exist, are next to none.

Perhaps Ostafrikasaurus is not a spinosaurid after all, but until we find more fossils one can imagine the possibilities.

3 thoughts on “December 17th

  1. I honestly NEVER expected you to cover Ostafrikasaurus. In fact, for a non-coelurosaurian theropod, I thought you’d do Asfaltovenator, Elaphrosaurus, Ozraptor, or even revisit Torvosaurus. In fact, I want to focus on one of the former three for my entry (I held of on covering any Jurassic animals because I was afraid we’d cover the same creature). But you present this African theropod well. It has appeared in some Jurassic World content, and I think we need more remains of it.
    Like I said before, I would like to do a Jurassic creature for my own advent counterpart of yours for this day. If you didn’t plan any of my non-coelurosaurs above (perhaps you’ve never heard of Asfaltovenator before I possibly brought it up a year ago, or also Ozraptor), then I’d like to go over one of them.

    Like

    1. Normally I wouldn’t feature a dinosaur with so few fossils to its name, but I just couldn’t pass up the opportunity of a possible spinosaurid during the Jurassic Period. 🙂

      There are many dinosaurs and other prehistoric creatures I do not know about, so it’s pretty likely a lot of people know the names of far more dinosaurs than I do. It’s one of the big reasons I like exploring an entire formation at a time, and my primary goal is to simply inspire curiosity and fun exploring.

      Like

      1. It appears you’re not planning any more theropods, so off to my subject of focus: Asfaltovenator. Known from the early Jurassic of Argentina from a formation originally though to be from the middle Jurassic, the remains of this allosauroid were unearthed in 2002. It is known from a partial skeleton, including a largely complete skull. This discovery is significant because while there is a great amount known about large theropods of the Cretaceous of South America, prior to Asfaltovenator’s description, the Jurassic theropods were lacking in decent fossil remains. The discovery and description of Asfaltovenator helped give a better picture on what the ancestries to the apex predators of Cretaceous South America would have been like.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s